Issue 9 |

Punctuation in the Digital Age

by on December 28, 2016

“A period goes at the end of every sentence.”
“Don’t overuse exclamation marks.”
“Don’t use a comma to separate two complete sentences.”
“Begin every sentence with a capital letter.”

If you’ve ever studied English in any sort of formal setting, such rules probably sound all too familiar. When it comes to standard written language, they remain important and relevant; after all, would you be able to take this article seriously had I forgotten to capitalize proper nouns or ended half the sentences with exclamation marks? In the world of (informal) electronic communication, however, punctuation conventions are rapidly changing and evolving (or devolving, depending on your perspective). What is considered correct and obligatory in formal writing might be seen as unnecessary or even pretentious in a more colloquial context. While much of what will be said here can be applied to any modern written language, this article will focus on English specifically due to its status as lingua franca of the 21st century and consequently, of the Internet.

Prescriptivism vs Descriptivism: How language is (or should be) used

There are two basic schools of thought in linguistics that can and should be referenced when discussing this issue. (Although prescriptivism and descriptivism are most often applied to grammar, they can be just as relevant to discussions of punctuation or of other elements of style.) The first of these, prescriptivism, holds that we should write and speak “properly” at all times — using “who” and “whom” correctly, for example, or separating two independent clauses with a semicolon. To the staunch prescriptivist, the relaxation of grammar and punctuation conventions that has come to characterize language use in the age of the Internet is indicative of the devolution or degeneration of English.

To the descriptivist, on the other hand, English is merely changing and has been since its inception — neither for the better nor for the worse. Descriptivism is the dominant camp in modern linguistics; its proponents maintain a focus on describing (as the name implies) how a language is actually spoken, written, and understood by those who use it. This should be done without value judgements (assuming that speakers of certain dialects are less intelligent than speakers of “standard” English, for example) or the establishment of normative rules such as those that define prescriptivism.

In theory, these two schools of thought exist independently of one another, but in practice, they often overlap. I, for one, understand and agree with descriptivist principles but still cannot help but cringe when I see the misuse of “your” and “you’re.” I also recognize that formal writing and discourse can follow a vastly different set of rules from informal electronic communication, and I adhere to diverse standards of usage based on my audience. This selective adherence to prescriptive rules is at the heart of understanding punctuation in the age of the Internet.

How is punctuation changing in the Digital Age?

The most obvious example of this is the full stop, or “period” in American English. According to linguist David Crystal, “in an instant message, it is pretty obvious a sentence has come to an end, and none will have a full stop. So why use it?” Its “conspicuous omission… in text messages and in instant messaging on social media,” he also argues, “is a product of the punctuation-free staccato sentences favoured by millennials — and increasingly their elders — a trend fuelled by the freewheeling style of Facebook, WhatsApp, and Twitter.” What’s more, according to Crystal, the seemingly-innocuous full stop can also be “deployed as a weapon to show irony, syntactic snark, insincerity, even aggression” — at least in casual communication. “The period now has an emotional charge and has become an emoticon of sorts,” he says. “In the 1990’s the Internet created an ethos of linguistic free love where breaking the rules was encouraged and punctuation was one of the ways this could be done.”

Almost as ubiquitous as the full stop is the comma, a symbol that should not technically be used to separate two independent clauses (sentences) as in the following example: I study linguistics, my specialty is syntax. When this does occur, it is known as a comma splice, and it is rapidly gaining acceptance in the Digital Age. Bryan A. Garner, considered the world’s top grammarian and a proud prescriptivist, has the following to say about this phenomenon: “More and more people are communicating with comma splices — perhaps in text messages and in email messages — and it could be that [they] will soon be somehow considered standard.” A comma splice can be fixed by replacing the comma with a semicolon (as in, I study linguistics; my specialty is syntax.), a punctuation mark whose lack of correct usage has angered many a grammarian. Much like the full stop, however, the semicolon used in casual exchanges has taken on charged connotations in recent years — namely, it can come across as pretentious or showy. In an attempt to avoid being labelled as such, I (and others with whom I have spoken) tend to use comma splices at least in text and instant messages despite knowing that they are prescriptively incorrect.

Comma splices and full stop elimination are only two among many examples of contemporary punctuation change. Others include a higher rate of exclamation marks (particularly of two or more in a row), the more relaxed use of apostrophes, and — although they are not technically punctuation — the myriad of emoticons, hashtags, and emoji that have come to define language use in the Digital Age. Like traditional punctuation marks, they too can be used to add nuance, feeling, and certain implications to a sentence; after all, the “face with tears of joy” emoji (?) was named the 2015 Word of the Year by Oxford Dictionaries, hailed — along with its many counterparts — as a “nuanced form of expression, and one that can cross linguistic barriers.”

Where do we go from here?

Once again, David Crystal has summed this all up aptly by stating that, “The big thing about language is that it always changes. Since the Internet came along, it has never moved so fast.” This change is inherently neither good nor bad, but it is inevitable, and punctuation in the Digital Age exemplifies it perfectly. According to “The Mysterious Origins of Punctuation,” written by Keith Houston of the BBC, the earliest readers and writers actually got by without it for thousands of years. Does technology guarantee an eventual return to that state? Only time will tell, but we are still using language to communicate creatively and effectively. And the beauty of language is that we will continue to do so, with or without current standard punctuation.


References

Bilefsky, D. (2016, June 9). Period. Full Stop. Point. Whatever It’s Called, It’s Going Out of Style. The New York Times, Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/10/world/europe/period-full-stop-point-whatever-its-called-millennials-arent-using-it.html

Liberman, Mark. (2016). Linguistics 001: Prescriptive and Descriptive Linguistics [Online]. Retrieved from http://www.ling.upenn.edu/courses/Fall_2016/ling001/prescription.html

McMahon, D. (2016, May 3). The world’s top grammarian fears that this punctuation error is becoming standard English. Business Insider, Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/comma-splice-2016-4

Raphel, A. (2015, December 10). A History of Punctuation for the Internet Age. The New Yorker, Retrieved from http://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/a-history-of-punctuation-for-the-internet-age

81 Responses to “Punctuation in the Digital Age”

  1. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  2. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Info here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  3. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  4. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  5. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  6. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  7. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  8. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  9. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  10. … [Trackback]

    […] There you will find 33909 additional Information on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  11. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  12. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  13. … [Trackback]

    […] Here you will find 91095 additional Information to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  14. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  15. … [Trackback]

    […] Info to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  16. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  17. … [Trackback]

    […] There you can find 23710 more Information on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  18. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  19. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  20. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  21. … [Trackback]

    […] There you can find 27544 additional Info on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  22. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  23. … [Trackback]

    […] Here you will find 32386 additional Info to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  24. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More Information here on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  25. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  26. Cheap Shoes China Wholesale

    The over-under on how many games the Patriots [url=http://www.cheapsuperstarchina.com/]Adidas Superstar Clearance Sale[/url] will win this season dropped from 10.5 to [url=http://www.steelersonlineteamshop.com/]Steelers Jersey Cheap[/url] 10 after Brad…

    Reply
  27. Adrian Wilson Jersey

    Guard Kelechi Osemele said that Mosley never acted like a rookie and expects the linebacker will improve plenty in his second season.

    Reply
  28. Air Max Outlet Online Italia

    ELIZABETH, N.J. (AP) 锟?New York Jets linebacker Jermaine Cunningham pleaded not guilty Wednesday to New Jersey charges that he shared explicit photos of a female friend.

    Reply
  29. … [Trackback]

    […] There you can find 46269 more Info on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  30. Jerseys Football Wholesale

    He’s completed only 61.6 percent of his passes and has a league-high-tying 10 interceptions [url=http://www.discountnfljerseys.us.com/discount-chicago-bears-aaron-lynch-jersey/]Aaron Lynch Jersey[/url] 锟?three returned for touchdowns.

    Reply
  31. Antonio Brown Jersey

    Wagner wouldn’t make it, though. He takes pride in the stinginess of his defense, but sees himself as a cog, nothing [url=http://www.cheapjerseysforstitched.us.com/]Football Jerseys Cheap Authentic[/url] more, in that frugality on the scoreboard.

    Reply
  32. Oakland Raiders t Shirts Cheap

    Davison is the fifth defensive player taken in New Orleans’ first seven picks as the Saints try to fortify [url=http://www.kankenbackpacksaleuk.com/]Kanken Backpack Sale UK[/url] a [url=http://www.cheapjerseysfastshipping.us.com/]Authentic Jerseys Sto…

    Reply
  33. China Jerseys

    General manager Trent Baalke believes there are plenty of options to replace Harbaugh [url=http://www.shoesbycheap.com/]Cheap Shoes Canada Online[/url] and ensure the Niners are contenders again. CEO Jed York won’t accept anything less.

    Reply
  34. Akiem Hicks Jersey

    Clausen threw three incomplete passes [url=http://www.buffalobillsshoponline.com/]Wholesale Buffalo Bills Jerseys[/url] after J.J. Nelson muffed a punt to give the Bears possession on the Arizona 22. Chicago then [url=http://www.sackankenpascher.fr/]Sa…

    Reply
  35. Cheap Shoes Australia Online

    Griffin participated in non-contact drills on Monday but remains in the NFL’s concussion protocol and won’t play in Thursday’s preseason finale against Jacksonville. Cousins is expected to [url=http://www.outletairmaxitalia.it/]Nike Air Max Scontate…

    Reply
  36. … [Trackback]

    […] Here you can find 72157 additional Info to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  37. … [Trackback]

    […] There you can find 99336 more Information to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  38. Adidas Stan Smith Clearance

    The start of camp marks the [url=http://www.nbasale.us.com/bob-cousy-jersey-boston-celtics/]Bob Cousy Jersey[/url] resumption of a three-way quarterback competition involving EJ Manuel, who lost his starting job last season, and new additions, journeym…

    Reply
  39. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Information here on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  40. … [Trackback]

    […] Here you can find 20916 additional Info to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  41. Duke Johnson Jersey

    So did the Falcons, the only head coaching vacancy that hasn’t been filled.

    Reply
  42. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More to that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  43. Al Horford Jersey

    Grigson did shed some light on other topics, though.

    Reply
  44. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  45. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  46. … [Trackback]

    […] Read More on that Topic: unravellingmag.com/articles/punctuation-in-the-digital-age/ […]

    Reply
  47. Cheap Jerseys From China

    Wayne, known for his No. 87 in Indy, comes to a team that already has a pretty good No. 87 锟?tight end Rob Gronkowski. That’s fine with Wayne, who will wear No. 15.

    Reply
  48. K?nken Ryggs?ck

    Havenstein and guard Jamon Brown, second- and third-round picks, went wire to wire in their NFL [url=http://www.wholesalejerseysforsale.us.com/]Wholesale Jerseys From China[/url] debuts. Coach Jeff Fisher said they finished as strong as they started.

    Reply
  49. Cheap Carolina Panthers Youth Jersey

    “I looked around the huddle and everybody had that mentality that we were going to score. Guys [url=http://www.kankenbackpackaustralia.com/]Fjallraven Kanken Australia Sale[/url] stepped up with some huge plays,” he said. “We moved on them the entir…

    Reply
  50. Stitched Arizona Cardinals Jerseys

    “In your eyes, you’re kind of just, ‘Hey, I played quarterback before. So, it’s I can see the coverage, man, zone, what the corner’s doing, linebackers, D-ends, stuff like that,’ ” he said. “It obviously helped.”

    Reply
  51. NMD Cheap Real

    Darby will have a chance to fill a backup role in a defensive backfield that returns starters Stephon Gilmore and [url=http://www.wholesaleukshoes.com/]Wholesale Cheap Shoes Uk[/url] Leodis McKelvin. His addition should allow veteran Corey Graham make…

    Reply
  52. Zapatillas Nike Mujer Espa?a

    HEALTHY RECEIVERS: Second-year receivers Allen Robinson and Marqise Lee will open camp on the field 锟?a welcome sight for the Jaguars. Both second-round draft picks in 2014, Robinson and Lee missed considerable time last season because of injuries. The…

    Reply
  53. Swell Uk

    With the Chargers leading 20-16, Attaochu threw McCown for a 12-yard loss from the Chargers 25. That forced the Browns to settle for Travis Coons’ 40-yard field goal.

    Reply
  54. Cheap Air Max 1

    “I think the biggest kick was the 33-yarder at the end just because it put us up six, and Baltimore was in the red zone at the end of the game and they would have tied it up,” McManus said. “So, that six-point differential was huge.”

    Reply
  55. Nike Dunk Wholesale China

    “Having kids, [url=http://www.swellflaskenorge.com/]Swell Flaske[/url] there’s just that realization even more to put a stop to all of these issues,” said Decker, the father of two young children. “I think it starts, obviously, at home with proper…

    Reply
  56. Discount Bears Jerseys

    Late in the third quarter, Rams defensive end William Hayes drew the ire of the Vikings and the crowd with a low hit on Bridgewater, who grabbed his right knee. That was not penalized.

    Reply
  57. Cheap Jerseys From China

    “I’ve been waiting for this since I was little, so I’m excited to get out there and play with [url=http://www.wholesalejordan12.com/]Jordan 12 Cheap Real[/url] the team,” Yeldon said Monday.

    Reply
  58. Swell Water Bottle Wholesale

    鈥擳he Chargers placed star receiver Keenan Allen on season-ending injured reserve with a lacerated kidney.

    Reply
  59. Cheap Jerseys From China

    Hoyer [url=http://www.cheapairmaxplusclearance.com/]Wholesale Air Max Plus[/url] and Hopkins pretty much had the game in hand well before Bortles’ most costly throw.

    Reply
  60. Swell Flaske

    The Dolphins looked very different coming off their bye and completely took the Titans (1-4) by surprise. Tennessee lost its fourth straight.

    Reply
  61. Camo China Football Jerseys

    They feel Williams is their man.

    Reply
  62. Aaron Ness Jersey

    Chicago punted on all 10 of its possessions. Matt Forte was held to 74 yards on 20 [url=http://www.swellbottlesnz.com/]sWell Bottle Stockists[/url] carries and the Bears finished with just 37 yards in the second half.

    Reply
  63. Swell Bottle Uk Sale

    Conley, a third-round Chiefs pick, made a nice reception at the goal line on his first touchdown of the preseason. He had three receptions for 38 yards.

    Reply
  64. Wholesale Football Jerseys China

    Fisher, for his part, says he has no plans to repeat that stunt.

    Reply
  65. Cheap Basketball Shoes Free Shipping

    Team president Jonathan Kraft said during the broadcast of the Patriots’ exhibition finale that the team would have postponed the ceremony if Brady was suspended for the game. Kraft said the team planned for an alternate banner that would note some of…

    Reply
  66. Lebron Shoes For Sale

    The 37-year-old says he doesn’t want his sons to feel entitled, adding “cause sometimes your best is not enough, and that should drive you to want to do better.”

    Reply
  67. Ultra Boost Wholesale

    It’s the second arrest since October for Randle, who faced a misdemeanor shoplifting charge at a Dallas-area mall after police in the suburb of Frisco say he was accused of taking $123 worth of cologne [url=http://www.wholesale95airmax.com/]Cheap Air…

    Reply
  68. Custom New York Jets Jersey

    “We have no accurate accounting of how many procedures he has had to date, nor specifically how invasive or how many times he has been put under anesthesia,” LeBlanc wrote to Baskin. “The current obstructionist behavior on his wife’s part is not to…

    Reply
  69. Cheap Jerseys Fast Shipping

    The election is scheduled for March 15, one day after each candidate will make their case to the 32 player reps who will ultimately vote.

    Reply
  70. NHL Jerseys Wholesale

    PROTECT MARIOTA: The Titans cut their losses, releasing right tackle Michael Oher in February and benching left guard Andy Levitre before recently trading him to Atlanta for two draft picks. That leaves new left guard Byron Bell as the [url=http://www.…

    Reply
  71. Stitched NFL Jerseys Outlet

    There was some thought that Wayne would try to talk Johnson into joining the Colts this time, but team owner Jim Irsay announced the Colts would not re-sign Wayne.

    Reply
  72. Clearance Nike Kd Shoes

    In matching [url=http://www.nhljerseyscanada.com/Cheap-washington-capitals-andre-burakovsky-jersey-canada-75-tz/]Andre Burakovsky Jersey[/url] the second-biggest collapse in team history, the Bucs wasted an outstanding offensive performance led by No.…

    Reply
  73. Cheap Wholelsale Football jerseys

    INDIANAPOLIS (AP) 锟?Andrew Luck still remembers the pressure he faced in Round 1 against Todd Bowles’ defense.

    Reply
  74. Cheap Vans Old Skool

    The district [url=http://www.airmax720wholesale.com/]Air Max 720 For Sale[/url] attorney’s office plans to dismiss that criminal complaint, it said, but could re-evaluate if more information becomes available. McDonald was released by the Chicago Bear…

    Reply
  75. Cheapest Yeezy Boost 350

    Kaepernick is sensing a shift.

    Reply
  76. Wholesale Jerseys Free Shipping

    “Of course you want to be out there, you want to be dressed, you want to have [url=http://www.cheapairmaxplusclearance.com/]Cheap Air Max Plus Sale[/url] an opportunity to get on the field,” Manuel said. “At first it is tough, but once I understood…

    Reply
  77. Swell Water Bottle Sale

    The Bristol County [url=http://www.ultraboostclearance.com/]Ultra Boost Sale[/url] district attorney’s office spent $360,462.30 on overtime for state police and $101,834.64 for expenses such as experts and travel, for a total of just over $462,000, sp…

    Reply
  78. Kyrie Irving Shoes For Sale Cheap

    Ole Miss said 27 NFL teams had representatives on campus.

    Reply
  79. Cheap Sneakers Wholesale

    Best Illustration: Jeff Basting, The (Toledo) Blade; Charlie Zimkus, The Columbus Dispatch, “Robo-advisers”; Tyler Post, The Columbus Dispatch, “Summer Reading: Sunshine & Darkness”.

    Reply
  80. Discount Jerseys

    But the possible return of Cherilus and Reitz could help solidify the makeshift line. Last weekend, rookie Jack Mewhort moved from left guard to right tackle for the first time. Shipley, who opened the season as the starting center, played left guard.…

    Reply
  81. Nike Air Vapormax From China

    A judge will determine whether the actor can overturn a divorce settlement with his second wife over extortion accusations.

    Reply

Leave a Comment