How do you visualise language learning? Perhaps you imagine building a tower, brick by brick. Or perhaps you see it more like furnishing an empty room. Or perhaps you swallow each word by the spoonful and let it become a part of you. Or perhaps you don’t think about what language learning is “like” much at all… but perhaps you should. Here’s a designer idea for how to start: think of a rope.
A few weeks ago, several hundred linguaphiles descended on a small theatre in New York City for the 2015 Polyglot Conference. Among the fascinating speakers at the conference was Michael Erard, journalist, author, and—this is the weird one—metaphor designer. Erard actually develops new metaphors as part of his career—he did it full time for five years at the FrameWorks Institute, and still does it for private sector clients and others.
Professionally designed metaphors like Erard’s are a little different from the poet’s or the writer’s. They’re not meant to be beautiful, he explains in Aeon Magazine. “They’re meant to make someone realise that they’ve only been looking at one side of a thing.” The creation process is quite rigorous. Erard reaches deep into linguistic and social theory and cognitive mapping, as well as spontaneous ingenuity, to come up with a number of possible metaphors for a concept. In detailed reports, he articulates at length the aptness and flexibility of the metaphor as well as its potential ramifications for public understanding. Finally, he tests the metaphors with members of the public by putting them through focus groups and posing them to people on the street. Only the ones that really work the way he wants them to make the cut.
Companies and organisations might pay for the development of a metaphor that helps to change the way people look or think about an issue. For example, one metaphor Erard helped design at the FrameWorks Institute proposed looking at children’s executive function as Air Traffic Control for Your Brain—organisation is important, and so is training and runway space to some extent, but ultimately there can only be so many planes in the air. This study was sponsored by The Center of the Developing Child at Harvard University as part of research on effective ways to communicate about the policy implications of science on early childhood development.
Erard even has a metaphor for metaphor, useful as he persuades potential clients of the usefulness of his work. For example, in “See Through Words”, he says he thinks of metaphors as a room whose windows and doors frame a certain view of the reality outside. The metaphor designer, then, is like the architect who places the windows and doors, guiding the viewer to share the perspective the architect intended.
Erard had come to the Polyglot Conference to share with us his metaphor for language learning, explaining that developing such a complex skill is like weaving a rope.
A good rope has many strands, which must be woven together tightly in order for the rope to be strong. The strands and the technique of weaving the rope can be compared with the skills learners begin with—their own special talents, their pre-existing related knowledge—as well as new skills they are developing and strengthening. But the rope won’t weave itself. Many strands or few, good technique or poor; what is perhaps most essential is the time and effort of weaving it all together. And once complete, the rope is a useable thing, a tool.
In a FrameWorks report written in March 2013, Erard explains and tests the idea of using rope weaving as a metaphor for learning in general. The Institute hoped it would be useful in explaining and arguing for educational policies.
“The metaphor,” Erard wrote, “enabled people to see that skills are dynamic, that learning is lifelong, and that the best way to create positive learning outcomes involves weaving social and emotional skill development into cognitive skill development.”
The metaphor also worked on an additional level—the purpose-oriented goal of the learning is also embedded in the comparison. After a rope is woven, it then functions as a useful tool—just as a new skill, once learned, can be used as a tool in life. Erard explains that the metaphor in fact works on three levels: the functional, the structural, and the processual:
“A rope is perhaps one of the few items that qualifies as a tool whose construction people can imagine, see, and perhaps even do. In other words, weaving ropes combines functional (what something does), structural (what something is made of) and processual (how something is made) entailments.”
Just like Erard says a good metaphor should do, as soon as I heard of the ropes metaphor, I felt that I intuitively grasped it and wanted to explore it further. It felt simple enough to offer a clear viewpoint, but flexible enough to incorporate many of the unique elements and variables of the learning process. It helped me see and talk about the landscape of learning in new ways.
I thought about the polyglots at the conference, and what the metaphor could mean for our language learning, which sometimes appears so exceptional to those less fascinated by foreign tongues. Perhaps polyglots come to the rope-weaving with a few more strands already at the ready (for some, perfect mimicry; for others, a good memory for vocabulary). And then, from the other languages we’ve woven, perhaps we already know some of the techniques and have prepared a few more strands (perhaps we’ve already figured out how to dominate tones, or can make the mental shift to a case-based language).
Certainly, we’re starting with more experience, more of a vision and more of a plan for our ropes than my elementary school Spanish students, who are still weaving their first conscious ropes and going about it a little blindly—albeit with a teacher guiding their hands. Budding linguaphiles working on their first foreign language-rope might find the process a bit frustrating at times, when more strands have to be spun from scratch and their developing technique makes progress sometimes slower than they would like. But if they stick with it, they’ll get better with time—this rope will be woven, and the next one will come easier.
But for brand new language learners, hyperpolyglots, and everyone else in between, one thing is certain: that rope isn’t going to weave itself. The time, the effort, the patience, the motivation, the basic action of weaving—and, for real fluency, the melding together of the cognitive with the social and emotional—still needs to happen.
Erard’s presentation was the first time I’d knowingly gazed through such a deliberately and professionally crafted metaphor window, and I was sold. The rope-weaving metaphor for language learning felt suggestive, helpful, and flexible—even, although I know it’s beside the point, beautiful.
45 Responses to “Weaving ropes of language”
katewins
Assignment Writers ensures complete confidentiality and privacy of all client information.
LauraHarris
Whether you’re new to gaming or a seasoned player, snake 3D offers an enjoyable and engaging experience. The game’s straightforward mechanics make it easy to pick up, while its challenging elements provide depth for experienced players.
Jones Elizabeth
I am extremely delighted in for this web journal. Its a useful subject. It help me all that much to take care of a few issues. Its chance are so awesome and working style so rapid. pin-badges
Jones Elizabeth
definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog! more about
진도출장샵
ming for all your guests. The family should be able to stay organized and enjoy spending time in this space. The family should have a good flow in the space, and it should be co진도출장샵mfortable and inviting. Luckily, there are a lot of easy and affordable ways to make this happen.
Nolan Jack
Hey everyone! I’m in the market for a new Kettle and considering buying one online in the UAE. If you’ve done the same, could you please share your experiences? I’d love to hear your thoughts on which brand/model you chose and how it’s been working out for you.
suzzain john
elizavecca makes it effortless to apply, and it’s suitable for all hair types.
Ingvar12
Take a leisurely stroll through the visual landscape of https://pornpax.com/categories/brunette/ , where every image and video showcases the essence of beauty personified through graceful girls. The platform stands as a testament to the timeless allure of elegance, offering a collection that’s both captivating and inspiring. The array of content available is more than just a feast for the eyes; it’s a journey into a world of aesthetic delight.
meme
Uncover the financial prowess of tennis icon Serena Williams on Celeb-networth.net. Beyond her Grand Slam victories, Williams has aced the business game, amassing wealth through endorsements, fashion ventures, and strategic investments.
alexander robbins
Proudly serving the Mesquite community, erofmesquite is your trusted partner in times of crisis, offering reliable and compassionate emergency care with the convenience of 24-hour emergency services
Kim
Optimize your organizational performance with meticulous Internal Audit services. Our expert team ensures transparency, compliance, and efficiency, providing valuable insights to drive strategic decision-making.
John Robert
Struggling to grow your Facebook audience? how to buy facebook followers and see your profile skyrocket! An easy and effective way to boost your social media presence quickly.
hasan memon
View the Kerala Lottery Result updates are a hot topic of discussion, with people from all walks of life waiting with bated breath to see if they are among the fortunate ones.
Online circket id
For a number of years, I have been marketing aWS credit accounts. You’ve come to the correct spot if you’re looking to obtain an AWS credit account.
Online circket id
Cricket Betting
For a number of years, I have been marketing aWS credit accounts. You have arrived to the correct site if you wish to obtain an AWS credit account.
Cricket Betting
cricket id
I’ve spent a number of years marketing aWS credit accounts. You’ve come to the correct spot if you’re looking to get an AWS credit account.
cricket id
cricket id
It’s been a few years since I started selling aWS credit accounts. This is the ideal location for you if you’re looking to obtain an AWS credit account.
cricket id
Best Cricket id Provider
For a number of years, I have been marketing aWS credit accounts. You’ve come to the correct spot if you’re looking to obtain an AWS credit account.
Best Cricket id Provider
Best betting id
For a number of years, I have been marketing aWS credit accounts. You have arrived to the correct site if you wish to obtain an AWS credit account.
Best betting id
Best betting id
I’ve spent a number of years marketing aWS credit accounts. You’ve come to the correct spot if you’re looking to get an AWS credit account.
Best betting id
Herman
When your child needs urgent medical attention, turn to erofdallastx for expert pediatric urgent care in Dallas.
bery
He froze as his office Dubai Call girls Call girls dubai Call girls in dubai Call girls at dubai Dubai Call girl Call girl dubai Call girl in dubai Indian Call girls dubai door opened. “Hey, Rex, you got a minute? ” Indian Dubai Call girls Call girl dubai Pakistan Call girls in dubai Pakistani.
Johny j
He froze as his office Dubai Call girls Call girls dubai Call girls in dubai Call girls at dubai Dubai Call girl Call girl dubai Call girl in dubai Indian Call girls dubai door opened. “Hey, Rex, you got a minute? ” Indian Dubai Call girls Call girl dubai Pakistan Call girls in dubai Pakistani.
chapter 7 bankruptcy lawyer near me
Thanks for sharing this informative content, I appreciate the great effort you put into providing such detailed information. chapter 7 bankruptcy lawyer near me
marytaylor075
Students find themselves stuck in assignments, exams, researching, and other activities and they know very well how much time these Online marketing assignment help uk.So we have now many writing assistants and the perks of hiring an in UK is it will save your time, your work will be correctly written
Michael
erofmesquite serves as a valuable alternative to the emergency room for non-life-threatening medical concerns
Ken
For non-life-threatening emergencies, our urgent care facility, mesquite er provides efficient medical attention without the wait of traditional emergency rooms, ensuring your health needs are met promptly.
Hasnain
For seamless travel in Leamington Spa, rely on Leamington Spa Taxis. With our fleet of vehicles and professional drivers, we offer convenient and reliable transportation services. Whether you need a ride to the airport, a trip around town, or transportation to a special event, Leamington Spa Taxis is here to ensure you reach your destination safely and comfortably.
Tiffany Welch
Excellent read about SEO migration services! In my opinion, one of the most important lessons is how crucial it is to prepare and carry out a migration strategy that protects your SEO work. Moving content is just one aspect of the problem; another is making sure each redirect is carefully mapped. I’d want to know more about any tools that can make this process go more smoothly.
bikini dubai
Looking to level up your vacation wardrobe? Dive into our pool-side perfect collection of the latest must-have women’s swimwear. From bikini separates that are sure to bikini dubai earn you some serious style points to effortlessly chic swimsuits, we’ve got your swimwear game covered this season. Get ready to turn heads at the beach club party with swimsuits and women’s bikinis in this season’s must-have prints and hues.
Zulqer
Located conveniently within reach, our Emergency Clinic prioritizes your health and well-being, ensuring that you receive the attention and treatment you need in times of crisis.
George
Whether you’re dealing with a bone injury, respiratory issues, or other health concerns requiring diagnostic imaging, x ray near me delivers precise results to support your medical care. Located conveniently nearby, our facility prioritizes patient comfort and satisfaction, ensuring a seamless and stress-free experience during your visit.
Adelle Smith
SEO is similar to the secret sauce for companies in Plano that want to stand out online. I appreciate you emphasizing its significance in this situation! SEO Plano‘s effect on local companies never ceases to astound me. I appreciate you highlighting its importance!
Ninja
Your blog exemplifies excellence in writing. digital marketing company in gwalior
SMM Panel
I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing. pak smm panel
Solar
I’m grateful for the insights shared in this blog. Thank you, author!
Mike
Welcome to our Emergency Room, where your health and well-being are our top priorities. Our experienced team of medical professionals is ready 24/7 to provide prompt and expert care for a wide range of medical emergencies.
Sharlene
The website world of solitaire caught my attention lately, and it’s been a great find! There is a fantastic selection of solitaire games that appeal to fans of the classics and those seeking a fresh take on the classic game. It’s simple to use and enjoyable to traverse because to the clear and welcoming UI. The adjustable choices and the opportunity to monitor my data over time are features that I value. It’s a terrific way to relax and keep my mind active during breaks. I heartily suggest it to everyone who likes solitaire!
Rayaan
Our IT Support Plano provides comprehensive, reliable, and efficient solutions to keep your business technology running smoothly. We offer round-the-clock monitoring, troubleshooting, and maintenance to ensure minimal downtime and maximum productivity.
polo
Slot machines, often referred to as “one-armed bandits,” have come a long way since their inception in the late 19th century. What started as a simple mechanical device has evolved into a sophisticated digital entertainment experience, captivating millions of players worldwide polototo
romantic
South Adelaide is a romantic getaway. Adelaide’s elegant vineyards, breathtaking scenery, and cozy restaurants provide leisure and adventure. Adelaide has several romantic weekend and long-term vacation locations. Luxury accommodation
realsoftpc
Your blog has become my go-to resource whenever I need information on [topic]. Thanks for being so reliable!
TreeSize Professional License Key
Vairt
These are so good topic to read. I got best knowledge from here. thanks for sharing i was exploring from so long. Plz keep sharing.Investment Properties
Leah
Really enjoyed this read. Your content is always so relevant and well-thought-out. Thanks for sharing!
https://crackpcstore.com/hma-pro-vpn-crack/
Vairt Real Estate
Very informative for me. I am glad to visit your site. It really helps me a lot. I appreciate you.
Investing with Vairt