Seeing as this is the first issue of Unravel, it might be befitting to answer the pertinent question of what a linguist does. While I constantly joke about how a linguist might possibly be someone who’s good at eating linguine—though the two are definitely not mutually exclusive—or we are often dismissed as translators, it wouldn’t do us, linguists, justice to say that we simply examine language. How many of us can name a famous linguist offhand anyway? While the philosophers have Aristotle, the sociologists have Karl Marx, the economists have Adam Smith, and our poetry-loving cousins have William Shakespeare, we have another William at hand—William Labov.
Now, read the first line of this article aloud. How did you pronounce ‘first’? Did you say it as /fəːst/ like the ‘fast’ in ‘breakfast’ or did you say it as /fərst/ with the /r/ emphasised? Believe it or not, your social background would probably have predicted your choice of pronunciation. Now try “party harder”. Now that you have become conscious of the /r/s, it is unlikely that you would have dismissed its pronunciation this time around. The pronunciation of /r/ is a feature that varies widely across different English-speaking regions. In England, most people in the South do not pronounce the ‘r’ in words like ‘park’, while others in parts of the North and West do. The United States offers a similar variation. This pronunciation can also depend on the social class of the speaker. Likewise, as dialects change over time, patterns of the /r/ usage will change as well.
This was essentially the focus of William Labov’s 1966 linguistic experiment on the presence of rhoticity (pronunciation of the /r/ sound before pauses and consonants) in the speech of the New York City population. The now-eighty-six-year-old Labov famously conducted this particular experiment in three different department stores in New York City—Saks, Macy’s and the now-defunct S. Klein—each patronised by a distinct social class of people. In a bid to analyse differences in the speech patterns of people from different social classes, he carried out what is known as a ‘rapid anonymous survey’. He went up to random salespersons at each store and asked, “Excuse me, where are the women’s shoes?” or “Excuse me, what floor is this?” Both questions were expected to yield the reply of “fourth floor”. He would then ask them to repeat their answer to observe if there was any change in rhoticity. The idea was for the question to be casual and anonymous, so that the informant would think that it was a normal salesman-customer interaction.
Indeed, a clear pattern was observed. It was seen that the staff at Saks, a higher-class store, were more likely to pronounce /r/, while employees at Macy’s and S. Klein were more likely to omit the /r/. The request to repeat the response confirmed that an emphatic repetition tended towards the yielding of the /r/ pronunciation. Aside from the apparent socioeconomic class differentiation, age also played a part in this difference: Younger speakers favoured rhoticity whereas the older generation had a preference for the r-less pronunciation. Labov’s observation of this age difference proved influential in the development of the ‘apparent time’ method of studying language change. As individuals do not change their speech very much as they age, we can study younger and older speakers as a way of looking at language change in a community. In the case of /r/ and New York City, Labov’s department store study confirmed that the city was moving away from r-lessness and towards a more standard American English ‘r-fulness’.
Replications of Labov’s study were later carried out by other linguists in 1986 (Fowler) and again in 2009 (Mather). Their observations confirmed Labov’s predictions about language change in New York: over the five decades, there was an increase in the number of r-ful salespersons. Interestingly, this change primarily occurred in the upper- and middle-class stores, whereas hardly any difference was observed in the lower-class range of stores. These studies demonstrate that, even within a single profession, a range of factors, including social class, can influence the way we speak.
On a personal level and as a Singaporean, this research on New York City’s r-fulness is particularly interesting: recent studies by local linguists found that Singapore English is undergoing a very similar process. Younger Singaporeans are increasingly prone to pronouncing the /r/ sound. This pattern also correlates with a higher education and socioeconomic status. Thus, although Singapore English has historical connections to British English, which is largely r-less, these studies suggest that our local dialect is on its way to becoming rhotic.
In a way, then, Singapore English is at the same transitional point today that English in New York City was at when Labov conducted his study in 1966. Putting it in the local setting, performing this experiment on sales service staff at Louis Vuitton, Topman/Topshop and Giordano in Singapore are likely to produce the same results. Although we would expect to see a similar pattern in speech behaviour, it might not be that distinct in Singapore as we are a small, cosmopolitan country with vague geographically-defined communities.
With this sociolinguistic knowledge in mind, we are left to wonder what the fate of us ordering our ‘cha/r/ kway teow’ and ‘roasted po/r/k’ at our hawker centres might be. Or, with the notion of rhoticity becoming more prestigious, what about ‘pasta/r/’ for this linguine lover?
37 Responses to “Labov and the R”
KyleEllis
howler truly an awe-inspiring placid thanks so much for joint i bequeath see this corking website every single solar day
RemyMaison
howler truly an impressive message thanks so much for share-out i leave call this swell site every unwed clarence shepard day jr.
RylandLandyn
rio truly an amazing content thanks so much for unselfish i bequeath confabulate this bang-up internet site every unwed sidereal day
LewisJedidiah
thank you so much for this impressive website me and my kin best-loved this message and brainstorm blackhatseo
FrankChris
thank you so much for this astonishing web site me and my class precious this contentedness and sixth sense
AllanRaul
thank you so much for this awesome website me and my family precious this contentedness and brainstorm
SaulIsaac
thank you so much for this awful internet site me and my household best-loved this contentedness and perceptivity
KingsleyZakai
thank you so much for this awe-inspiring site me and my kin precious this message and insight
Betmate
먹튀없는업체 먹튀검증 지금바로 접속하세요
JeremiahRhett
thank you so much for this impressive site me and my household loved this content and perceptiveness
RowanKayson
thank you so much for this awful internet site me and my kin best-loved this self-complacent and perceptivity
GarrettBrian
thank you so much for this awful internet site me and my household best-loved this contentedness and perceptivity
DukeLeland
thank you so much for this impressive web site me and my phratr loved this self-complacent and penetration
LionelYousef
thank you so much for this awe-inspiring web site me and my sept loved this depicted object and brainstorm
KyloDamon
😀 thank you so much for this awe-inspiring site me and my phratr admired this satisfied and insight
PrinceBrecken
😀 thank you so much for this astonishing web site me and my phratr loved this contentedness and sixth sense
KeeganCalvin
😃 thank you so much for this astonishing website me and my phratr admired this message and sixth sense
LukeTy
😄 thank you so much for this awesome website me and my household preferent this contentedness and brainstorm
BraylonMaverick
😄 thank you so much for this astonishing site me and my household favored this depicted object and insight
CoenRoyal
😄 thank you so much for this awful website me and my sept best-loved this depicted object and perceptiveness
AaronEmir
😄 thank you so much for this awful web site me and my class loved this self-complacent and perceptiveness
BanksConrad
😀 thank you so much for this astonishing site me and my class preferent this satisfied and penetration
HamzaBjorn
😄 thank you so much for this awesome web site me and my sept favored this satisfied and brainstorm
DonovanAbraham
😃 thank you so much for this astonishing internet site me and my sept favored this self-complacent and perceptiveness
FrederickKing
😀 thank you so much for this awesome website me and my class preferent this contentedness and brainstorm
AhmadElias
😃 thank you so much for this astonishing website me and my household admired this content and penetration
mike remedios
뱃할맛이 나는곳 먹튀검증 안전한메이져
SolomonColt
😄 thank you so much for this awful website me and my family loved this contentedness and perceptiveness
carl remedios
검증된업체 먹튀검증 안전한 그곳 접속하세요
DiegoEmory
😃 thank you so much for this impressive website me and my kin favored this satisfied and insight
carl remedios
최고의 메이져 먹튀검증 이곳에서 즐기세요
BenjaminDion
😃 thank you so much for this awful web site me and my household preferent this self-complacent and sixth sense
carl remedios
뱃할맛이 나는곳 먹튀검증 안전한메이져
CasinoMecca
CasinoMecca
mike remedios
에볼플레이 먹튀검증 안전노리터
baccaratcommunity
Your writing is perfect and complete. baccaratcommunity However, I think it will be more wonderful if your post includes additional topics that I am thinking of. I have a lot of posts on my site similar to your topic. Would you like to visit once?
casinocommunity
I’ve been troubled for several days with this topic. casinocommunity, But by chance looking at your post solved my problem! I will leave my blog, so when would you like to visit it?