What’s the best age to learn a new language? Like most things in life, the answer is probably an evasive “it depends.”
“Wow, I bet they just soak it up like sponges!”
When I started teaching elementary school Spanish, I frequently heard such comments from my friends, my students’ parents, and others.
The idea that children learn languages especially quickly and easily is certainly widespread. It’s supported by both common sense and a substantial body of research touting the flawless mimicking ability and extraordinary plasticity of young brains (Lenneberg, 1967; Penfield & Roberts, 1959; Krashen, Long, & Scarcella, 1979).
According to the “critical period” hypothesis, children must acquire a first language in early childhood or forever lose the ability to master speech like that of a native speaker—and the hypothesis is often extended, albeit in a less extreme form, to second language acquisition. Such ideas have encouraged throngs of parents to sign their tots up for language courses, and simultaneously discouraged them from hitting the books themselves. But are they entirely true?
According to popular belief, my students should be breathing in the language almost accidentally. But I’ve had first graders cheerfully greet me with, “Hola, amigos!” and fifth graders cower in fear the first dozen times I presented them with a full sentence.
Once, a preschooler who spoke French at home and was usually silent at school answered my “¿Cuántos gatos hay?” with a hesitant “un, deux, trois…” and an uncertain flash of the eyes. Stuck between a sigh and a smile, I reminded him “quatre, cinq” and gave him his sticker. Sometimes, being three is tough enough in one language.
Even in pronunciation—that stronghold of critical-period supporters—there were disappointments: strange substitutions for tricky sounds and stubborn skewing towards the quirks of the written language. So, am I just the worst teacher ever, or are these guys just not as linguistically brilliant as they’re cracked up to be?
Meanwhile, I have friends who are learning complex languages, even on their own, well into their teens, twenties, thirties, and beyond. Are they all in possession of a rare ability to continue learning in their linguistic twilight years? Or is fluency within reach for anyone… if they dare to stick their neck out?
Other studies have found flaws in the old “childlike ease” theories; some showing equivalent or even faster language-learning progress in learners who are in their adolescence and beyond (McLaughlin, 1992; Geneses, 1981; Harley, 1989; Newport, 1990; Stern, Burstall, & Harley, 1975; Florander & Jansen, 1968; Asher and Price, 1967; Snow & Hoefnagel-Hoehle, 1978).
That’s not to say that there’s no benefit to teaching children languages. To the contrary, language learning can open children’s minds in a variety of ways, such as fostering a cross-cultural perspective and developing critical thinking skills.
Still, there is probably no single best age to learn a language. After all, what do we even mean by best? Speed? Ease? Native-level pronunciation and subtleties? Older children and adult learners may not make phonological distinctions as readily or grasp the finest shades of meaning quite as intuitively as a young child, but, in exchange, they have metacognition—the ability to understand their own learning process—and other tools that babies don’t. Having already mastered at least one language, they don’t need to learn a new one from the ground up—and maybe shouldn’t. They have the self-determination and the resources to pick a language to study and delegate their own time and money to it. They are also more likely to have greater self-discipline, patience, and perspective.
One reason children may seem to learn languages faster than adults is simply that they are more likely to find themselves in ideal language-learning environments: immersive, high-motivation situations, such as immigrating—through no choice of their own—to a new country and being put into a new school surrounded by both teachers and peers who do not speak their native language. Is it any wonder then that they learn faster, in that environment, than their parents who may be able to keep speaking their native tongue in their workplace or community, and must balance language-learning with a variety of adult responsibilities? As young children have a smaller vocabulary and use less complex grammar than adults, they also have less distance to make up between a new acquired language and their native language—possibly further adding to the illusion of speed and ease in language acquisition.
Perhaps one of the simplest ways to understand it comes down to this: the youngest children are still developing their native languages and how to think in general. On one hand, learning languages while this is all still coming together means the language has the chance to be wound up in this original understanding, giving the kid that often longed-for native pronunciation and execution if they keep up with the language throughout their education.
On the other hand, it may take children just as long, if not longer, to achieve functional use of the new language, since they are still building their own. My preschoolers can hardly be expected to memorise the names of numbers or colors in Spanish when they are still working out how to count or divide the visual spectrum into their distinct and correct names in any language. For adult learners, why reinvent the wheel, trying to understand tough grammatical concepts from the ground up when a simple analogy to your own language might provide a completely suitable shortcut?
As far as the “child-like ease” theory encourages teaching children languages, it doesn’t hurt. But when it discourages adults from engaging in language study—believing it to already be too late—it can do real harm. After all, by the time someone is old enough to read about the latest language-acquisition research, they are usually past the so-called critical period.
When adults talk about languages, they’ll often take on a sort of wistful tone. “I always wanted to learn Spanish,” they’ll say, or “I wish I could speak German.” Such laments imply that the window of opportunity for language learning is over, and the child-learner theory only fuels that sense of futility.
But take heart! There are many people learning languages later in life. Consider Ellen Jovin, the polyglot behind the Words and Worlds of New York language blog and grammar company Syntaxis. Now 50 years old, Jovin’s language studies are still going strong—she’s currently tackling Arabic and Swedish, among others.
Jovin explains that she doesn’t think language learning has gotten noticeably harder for her through the years, and notes that if she is past her peak for proper pronunciation, she has probably been over that hill since puberty. “I may forget more things,” she writes, “but if I do, I forget I have forgotten them, so I feel utterly untroubled.”
Are there advantages to ageing when it comes to language learning? Jovin finds grammar easier as her accumulated knowledge aids her in understanding new languages. And, more importantly, she says “I have oodles more patience than when I was younger, and I know how to manage myself better and keep myself motivated, how to accept and outsmart my weaknesses, and those benefits outweigh any drawbacks of aging for me. My only complaint is that my feet hurt today.”
While a lot of people learning languages later in life are “polyglots” who are already quite comfortable with the concept of learning another language, there is no reason to believe that such a task is impossible for those embarking on their second-ever language. Irish polyglot Benny Lewis, of Fluent in 3 Months fame, didn’t start learning languages until his 20’s—after college and well past the fabled sweet spot of early childhood. His late start hasn’t prevented him from reaching fluency in seven languages and a conversational level in four more.
The greatest challenge for older language learners may be psychological rather than intellectual.
“People think they’re too old, which makes them too old,” says Jovin.
“Being willing to take chances with new things, being willing to laugh at yourself, being willing to be a beginner at one thing even if you are used to being a leader or boss in other aspects of your life, learning to let go of self-consciousness, remembering that many people actually bloom intellectually later in life—these things all support effective language-learning as an older person.”
69 Responses to “Language learning at any age”
katewinsl
Thomas is a patient and knowledgeable do my online classes for me mentor who is committed to helping his students reach their goals.
tom
I’ve been using privatewriting for a while now, and their service is top-notch. The writers are professional and always deliver quality work on time. Highly recommended!
부여출장샵
Girls like to follow you. Now a day, “Gingham” fabric is trending. They are p부여출장샵urchased and wear it. Moreover, Stop Dump N Roll brought a Dumpster Rental Company in Lafayette LA service to your surrounding.
강남가라오케
강남셔츠룸
Andrew Gordon
Nursing blogs are my digital mentors. Reading about the experiences of seasoned nurses on their blogs https://www.nursingpaper.com/blog/how-to-write-a-nursing-diagnosis/ is like having a cup of coffee with a wise friend. It’s not just about the clinical knowledge; it’s about learning the nuances of the profession that textbooks often miss. Truly invaluable for any nursing student.
Visa and Immigrations
Privatewriting excels with professional writers delivering quality work promptly. Highly recommend their top-notch service for excellence
conta da binance
I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article. https://www.binance.info/pt-BR/join?ref=RQUR4BEO
pattyblack17
Exploring language acquisition across all ages requires insightful analysis, where a case brief writing service can be instrumental. By examining case studies and research findings, these services elucidate the effectiveness of various language learning methods for different age groups. Whether young or old, understanding the nuanced approaches to language learning empowers individuals to embark on their linguistic journey with confidence and efficacy.
SAFETOTO
It’s a game. Five dollars is free. Try it It’s not an easy game
->-> 카지노사이트 .COM
Safe Toto
It’s a game. Five dollars is free. Try it It’s not an easy game
->-> 카지노검증업체 .COM
SafeTotoSafeToto
It’s a game. Five dollars is free. Try it It’s not an easy game
->-> 온라인카지노 .COM
z-libary
It is a place of convergence, where diverse perspectives intersect, ideas collide, and friendships flourish. From the hushed whispers of solitary readers to the animated discussions of book clubs, the library buzzes with the energy of intellectual curiosity.
Solar
Thank you for making this topic less confusing. I understand it better now.
Nursing Thesis Writing Services
I want to always read your blogs. I love them Are you also searching for Nursing writing Help? we are the best solution for you.
Nursing paper writing services
I want to always read your blogs. I love them. Are you also searching for nursing writing services ? we are the best solution for you. We have a team of professional nursing writers that will work to give you the best assignments.
cheap nursing writing company
Great Platform. Are you also searching for need help with capstone project ? we are the best solution for you. We are best known for offering the best nursing essay writing services
drift hunters
The critical period hypothesis posits that there is a window in early childhood during which language acquisition occurs most naturally and efficiently. If children do not acquire a first language within this critical period, they may never achieve native-like proficiency. This hypothesis is often extended to second language acquisition, suggesting that younger learners have a distinct advantage.
Ninja
Fascinating insights into the cognitive benefits of language learning at any age! digital marketing company in gwalior
Call Girls in Punjabi Bagh
This article provides a clear and insightful analysis of Ashok Vihar Escorts. The author’s thorough research and structured presentation make it an invaluable read.
Pride Plaza Aerocity Call Girls
I appreciate how this article delves deep into Escorts in Pride Plaza Hotel Delhi, offering fresh perspectives and well-supported arguments. It’s evident that the author has a deep understanding of the topic
Independent Delhi Escorts
The author’s passionate exploration of VIP Delhi Call Girls shines through in this article. It’s evident they have a genuine commitment to advancing understanding in this field.
Aerocity Escorts
This article not only informs but also inspires. The author’s passion for Escorts in Hauz Khas is contagious and motivates readers to delve deeper into the issues discussed.
Delhi Escorts Service
The insights provided in this article have broadened my understanding of Escorts in Pune, offering a fresh perspective that challenges conventional wisdom.
Agra Escorts
I found this article to be refreshingly unbiased, presenting different sides of the debate on Escorts in Meerut with fairness and intellectual rigor.
Karol Bagh Escorts Service
This article is a valuable contribution to the literature on Escorts Service in 5 Star Hotels Delhi, offering a comprehensive overview that is accessible to both specialists and general readers
Delhi Call Girl Service
I appreciate how this article synthesizes complex theories into practical implications for South Delhi Call Girls Service, making it a valuable resource for professionals
the bangalore
Whether you’re looking for a fun night out on the town or just want someone to talk to, call girls can provide the companionship and entertainment you desire. Goa Escorts ||
the bangalore
Escorts in Chembur || Affordable rates available, you can enjoy all the benefits of a call girl service without breaking the bank.
the bangalore
Escorts Service in Dwarka || Join Dwarka escorts its safe and secure
the bangalore
Call Girls in Goa || In conclusion, call girls services are becoming more popular and widely available, with affordable rates that can fulfill your dreams and desires.
the bangalore
Whether you’re seeking companionship or entertainment, call girls can provide the services you need at a price that won’t break the bank. Call Girls in Delhi ||
Goa Escort
I’m would have rather not uncovered this site page. Escorts in Jaipur I expected to thank you in your time for this, especially perplexing read !! I genuinely without question delivered an impression of paying little mind to the full scale it and from having you saved to fav to check out at new information for your site.
Delhi Escorts
A commitment of appreciation is everything considered for the shocking spread you scattered. Goa Escort I like the way in which you paint the extraordinary substance. The focuses you improve are legitimate and reasonable. I’m unequivocal assistance with acing portraying for you
Hyderabad Escort Service
Excellent article, it was uncommonly useful! Escort in Goa I just started in this and I’m turning out to be more familiar with it better. The post is written in an exceptionally decent way and it contains numerous helpful data for me. Many thanks and will search for additional postings from you.
Escorts Service in Delhi
I’m obviously volatile to say that truly is a genuinely reestablishing article to work with everything. Goa Escorts I will know new information from the article; you are working acceptably. Keep on moving!
crackhints
Your passion for [topic] shines through in every post. Thanks for inspiring us!
Bitwar Data Recovery Unlocked Version
the bangalore
Understanding and respecting each other’s boundaries can lead to a more fulfilling and satisfying relationship. Escorts Service in Sanvordem ||
the bangalore
In conclusion, while the idea of joining an escort service may seem alluring, it is important to consider the potential risks and consequences involved. Bardez Escorts Service ||
the bangalore
Prioritizing safety, respect, and healthy relationships is crucial in making informed decisions.
Escorts Service in Anjuna Beach ||
the bangalore
Instead of seeking out quick fixes, it is recommended to explore alternative ways to fulfill fantasies that align with ethical and moral values. Bangalore College Escorts ||
the bangalore
Escorts service is here come join us and fulfill your fantasies” is a message that can be seen on various online platforms and advertisements. Bangalore Bhabhi Escorts ||
the bangalore
While the idea of joining an escort service may sound exciting and enticing, it is important to understand the implications and risks involved in such a decision. Bangalore air hostess Escorts ||
the bangalore
Escorts are individuals who are hired to accompany someone to social events, dinners, or even provide companionship. Escorts Service in Ponda ||
Kaitlyn
Great job on this post! Your writing is engaging, and the content is very helpful.
https://cracktopc.com/eset-nod32-antivirus-crack/
binance open account
Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me.
Dang k'y binance us
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks! https://www.binance.com/ph/join?ref=YY80CKRN
pune Escort
In the event that you are thinking about some happiness and searching for some friendly delight, as a major aspect of Model Escorts in Pune, let me stretch out a warm welcome to Sonal Mitra Pune Escorts.
Ahmedabad Escort
Best Ahmedabad Call Girls Get the Best Famous Services And Enjoy Yourself Fully When You Book Beautiful Ahmedabad Escorts Service . We guarantee that you will be completely satisfied.
Escort in Chennai
Our gorgeous escort females are experienced and skilled at satisfying your every need while making you cum. When it comes to their work, our Chennai Escorts Service is really professional.
entertenment studio
Reporting on health disparities requires journalists to navigate complex social, economic, and political issues that contribute to unequal access to healthcare and health outcomes. This coverage is essential for raising awareness of the challenges faced by marginalized communities and for advocating for policy changes that promote health equity. Journalists must be committed to providing accurate and compassionate reporting that highlights the experiences of those affected by health disparities and that explores potential solutions.News
alexahills654321
The service is known for maintaining discretion, ensuring that all your interactions are kept confidential. From beauty to charm,Dehradun Escorts Service is dedicated to providing top-tier service that meets your every need. Book now for an unforgettable time!”
zain
Safety is a top priority in motorsports, with innovations like the “halo” device in F1, which protects the driver’s head in case of an accident. In NASCAR, HANS devices (Head and Neck Support) and reinforced [url=https://councilsports.com/]Car Sports[/url] roll cages are critical to reducing injury risks.
zain
Safety is a top priority in motorsports, with innovations like the “halo” device in F1, which protects the driver’s head in case of an accident. In NASCAR, HANS devices (Head and Neck Support) and reinforced Car Sports roll cages are critical to reducing injury risks.
uzairshaikh
Drag racing is all about speed in a straight line. Two cars compete to see who can cover a set distance the fastest. Though the races are short, usually lasting just a few seconds, the rush of seeing cars accelerate to incredible speeds is enough to leave fans breathless. [url=https://councilsports.com/]Car sports[/url]
uzairshaikh
“Drag racing is all about speed in a straight line. Two cars compete to see who can cover a set distance the fastest. Though the races are short, usually lasting just a few seconds, the rush of seeing cars accelerate to incredible speeds is enough to leave fans breathless.
Drag racing is all about speed in a straight line. Two cars compete to see who can cover a set distance the fastest. Though the races are short, usually lasting just a few seconds, the rush of seeing cars accelerate to incredible speeds is enough to leave fans breathless.Car sports
“
24kbet
I am committed to fostering a positive and respectful environment where every voice is heard and valued. I encourage you to share your thoughts, engage in meaningful conversations, and support one another. Together, let’s create a space that inspires and uplifts us all. 24kbet
ahmedhassan
If you’ve ever seen a car chase scene in a blockbuster movie, you know just how captivating the speed and intensity can be. Films like The Fast and the Furious franchise have helped bring car sports to the forefront of popular culture. These movies not only showcase the thrill of high-speed chases but also glamorize the car culture that surrounds it. Car sports
ahmedhassan
NASCAR races are known for their high-speed action and close-quarter battles on oval tracks. The cars may look like everyday sedans, but underneath, they are engineering masterpieces. Car sports
Ctkoot
Wow.. great blog post, thanks for sharing it.
Cg Lovers
Great post, really interesting
For independent call girls profile please visit cglovers.com . Here you will find all genuine call girls service with out any scam or fraud. All profile details are real .
Bangalore Escorts
Are you seeking a high-class escort service in Bangalore? We offer gorgeous, professional companions fully dedicated to ensuring you have an unforgettable experience. It’s either fun nights on the town or cozy, private evenings – each experience guaranteed as per your wish. Secure and confidential bookings, coupled with support 24/7, assure you of your discretion and comfort.
tacoinquisitivelyb271cea3e4
Our service provides you with the opportunity to experience something truly unique and special. Our Ct Hookers Call Girls are some of the most beautiful and talented in the city, and they know how to have a good time. Whether you’re looking for a night of passion or just a fun evening out, our charming will make sure that you have a great time.
Visit Website: https://www.cthookers.com
Charles Morrow
オンカジのプロモーションは、シーズンごとに更新されるため、プレイヤーに常に新鮮な体験を提供します。
https://www.outlookindia.com/plugin-play/%E6%9C%80%E9%AB%98%E3%81%AE%E3%82%AA%E3%83%B3%E3%83%A9%E3%82%A4%E3%83%B3%E3%82%AB%E3%82%B8%E3%83%8E%E3%82%B5%E3%82%A4%E3%83%88%E3%82%92%E8%A6%8B%E3%81%A4%E3%81%91%E3%82%8B%E6%96%B9%E6%B3%95
Rentalbabe
This is the Call Girls Finder directory, which offers a wide range of companions to the client we wish to enjoy with her.
delicatelyperfection0dec962a50
Amazing story!
delicatelyperfection0dec962a50
Very nice movie! https://www.selectyourgirl.com
xvideos
The 24betting download is a reliable platform for lottery ticket sales and management, delivering a seamless and secure experience tailored for lottery enthusiasts.
Jyoti Sharma
Such a fantastic blog! You’ve explained the information so clearly, making it simple to understand and implement. I’m excited to try some of the tips you’ve shared. Keep up the amazing work.
Hi my name is Jyoti Sharma. We are provides Exclusive Escort Service In Delhi at reasonable rates. Our agency has experience of several years and we already fulfill the needs of almost 1000+ customers previous year. If You want escort service in Delhi then contact us.
Buy Adult Backlinks
If you’re running an adult website, you know how crucial it is to rank high on search engines like Google.Buy Adult Backlinks